Stress Fracture on Bone Scan

Understanding Stress Fracture on Bone Scan

Stress fracture is a common overuse injury that occurs when bone cannot withstand repetitive mechanical stress. Unlike acute fractures caused by a single traumatic event, stress fractures develop gradually from repeated microtrauma that overwhelms the bone's ability to repair itself. Bone scintigraphy is one of the most sensitive imaging modalities for detecting these injuries.

There are two main types of stress fractures:

1. Fatigue fractures: Occur in normal bone subjected to abnormal repetitive stress (common in athletes and military recruits)
2. Insufficiency fractures: Occur in weakened bone subjected to normal daily stress (common in elderly patients with osteoporosis)

Why Bone Scan Is Valuable for Stress Fractures

Bone scintigraphy offers several advantages for stress fracture evaluation:

Early detection—Bone scan can detect stress fractures 1-3 weeks before they become visible on X-ray. The increased bone turnover associated with stress fracture causes intense radiotracer accumulation, making these injuries clearly visible.

High sensitivity—Bone scan detects 95-100% of stress fractures, compared to only 50-70% for initial X-rays. This makes it the gold standard when X-rays are negative but clinical suspicion remains high.

Whole-body assessment—Bone scan can identify multiple stress fractures throughout the body, which is important because up to 20% of patients have more than one stress fracture.

Assessment of fracture age—The pattern of uptake on three-phase bone scan helps determine how recent the fracture is, which guides return-to-activity decisions.

Imaging Appearance of Stress Fractures

Three-Phase Bone Scan Findings

Three-phase bone scan is particularly useful for stress fractures:

Phase 1 (blood flow): Shows increased blood flow to the fracture site in acute fractures (first few weeks). This appears as a focal area of increased activity immediately after tracer injection.

Phase 2 (blood pool): Shows increased soft tissue activity around the fracture site in the acute phase. This helps distinguish acute fractures from chronic injuries.

Phase 3 (delayed images): Shows intense focal uptake at the fracture site. This is the most sensitive phase and becomes positive within 24-48 hours of injury.

Typical Stress Fracture Locations

Different activities cause stress fractures at characteristic locations:

Running and jumping sports:

• Tibia (shin bone): Most common site, especially distal third
• Fibula: Especially distal fibula
• Metatarsals: Second and third metatarsals most common
• Navicular and tarsal bones: Common in sprinters and jumpers
• Femoral neck: Serious location requiring urgent attention

Military recruits:

• Calcaneus (heel bone): From marching with heavy boots
• Metatarsals: From forced marching
• Femur: From prolonged marching and running

Insufficiency fractures (elderly, osteoporotic patients):

• Sacrum: Classic "H-shaped" fracture pattern
• Pubic rami: Common in elderly
• Femoral neck: Risk of displacement
• Subtrochanteric femur: Atypical fracture pattern

Clinical Applications

Diagnosing Suspected Stress Fracture

When athletes or active individuals develop bone pain:

• Confirm diagnosis when X-rays are negative
• Identify fracture location precisely
• Assess fracture age through scan pattern
• Detect additional fractures elsewhere in skeleton
• Guide treatment and return-to-activity timeline

Differentiating from Other Conditions

Bone scan helps distinguish stress fractures from:

Shin splints (medial tibial stress syndrome):

• Shows elongated, linear uptake along tibial cortex
• Less intense than stress fracture
• More diffuse distribution
• Earlier stage of bone stress continuum

Complete fracture:

• Shows very intense uptake with defined disruption
• May show displacement on delayed images
• Requires urgent orthopedic evaluation

Osteomyelitis:

• Shows increased flow and blood pool activity
• May appear more diffuse
• Clinical correlation with fever and elevated inflammatory markers

Treatment and Recovery

Treatment Approach

Stress fracture treatment depends on location and severity:

Low-risk fractures (e.g., distal tibia, fibular shaft, metatarsals):

• Rest from aggravating activity for 4-8 weeks
• Maintain cardiovascular fitness with swimming or cycling
• Gradual return to activity after pain resolves
• Bone scan shows healing with decreasing uptake intensity

High-risk fractures (e.g., femoral neck, tarsal navicular, fifth metatarsal base):

• More aggressive management required
• May require non-weight bearing or surgery
• Prolonged recovery period (3-6 months)
• Close monitoring for complications

Return to Activity

Bone scan helps guide return-to-activity decisions:

• Healing fracture: Shows decreasing uptake intensity over time
• Persistent activity: May indicate ongoing healing or need for continued rest
• Comparison studies: Serial scans can document healing progress

Most fractures show decreased uptake by 6-8 weeks, allowing gradual return to activity.

Evidence-Based Outcomes

Prevention Strategies

Risk Reduction

Preventing stress fractures involves:

• Gradual training progression: Increase mileage/intensity by no more than 10% per week
• Adequate nutrition: Calcium, vitamin D, and sufficient calories
• Proper equipment: Well-fitting, appropriate footwear
• Cross-training: Alternate high-impact with low-impact activities
• Recovery time: Allow adequate rest between training sessions
• Biomechanical assessment: Address gait abnormalities or leg length discrepancies

Preparing for Your Scan

Before the Appointment

• Hydration: Drink plenty of water before and after
• Medications: Take usual medications
• Activity history: Provide details about training and symptoms
• Previous imaging: Bring X-rays for correlation

Day of the Procedure

The scan takes 3-4 hours:

1. Tracer injection: Tc-99m MDP injected intravenously
2. Immediate imaging: Blood flow and blood pool phases (first 30 minutes)
3. Uptake period: Wait 2-3 hours for tracer incorporation into bone
4. Delayed imaging: Whole-body images acquired

Understanding Your Results

Frequently Asked Questions

How accurate is bone scan for stress fractures?

Bone scan detects 95-100% of stress fractures, making it the most sensitive imaging test for this injury. It can detect stress fractures 1-3 weeks before they appear on X-ray.

Do I need to stop exercising before the scan?

No, you don't need to stop exercising before the scan. However, if you have a recent stress fracture, it will still be visible regardless of recent activity. The scan shows bone turnover that persists for weeks to months.

Will I need another scan to confirm healing?

Many patients benefit from follow-up imaging to confirm healing before returning to full activity. Your doctor will determine whether repeat bone scan, X-ray, or MRI is appropriate based on your fracture location and clinical course.

Can I run again after a stress fracture?

Yes, most athletes return to running after stress fracture healing. The key is allowing adequate time for healing (typically 6-12 weeks) and following a gradual return-to-running program. Some stress fractures (like femoral neck) require more caution and may have longer return-to-sport timelines.

References

1. American College of Radiology. ACR Appropriateness Criteria: Stress Fracture. 2024.
2. American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons. AAOS Clinical Practice Guidelines: Stress Fractures. 2023.
3. American Journal of Sports Medicine. Meta-analysis of Bone Scintigraphy in Stress Fracture Detection. 2023.

---

Medical Disclaimer: This information is educational only. Always discuss findings with your healthcare provider for personalized medical advice.